Chris Drury entered the 2025-26 season knowing the New York Rangers were running out of excuses.
After years of playoff disappointment, a failed “win-now” push, and growing questions surrounding the organization’s player development system, the Rangers president and general manager unveiled “Letter 2.0,” promising a retool instead of a rebuild and effectively waving the white flag on the season. Instead of stabilizing the franchise, the Rangers finished near the bottom of the Eastern Conference and now head into another massive offseason surrounded by more questions than answers.
The message to fans, released in mid-January, acknowledged disappointment with how the year had gone and proclaimed the pivot would be geared toward building a team around speed, skill, and younger players. The organization also made it clear that changes would likely include moving on from certain veteran pieces in order to gain flexibility and future assets, as winning with the group in place was no longer realistic. The first domino was Carson Soucy to the Islanders for a third-round pick, and then on February 4th, the inevitable transpired. The biggest swing came when the Rangers moved Artemi Panarin, a franchise stalwart, to the Los Angeles Kings.
Drury received Liam Greentree and a 2026 third-round pick. The Kings also quickly extended Panarin on a 2-year, $22 million deal. Because he had a full no-move clause, Panarin held most of the leverage in the situation, and Drury didn’t have many clean options once the decision was made to move on. From that standpoint, the return was always going to be limited. Still, getting a young prospect like Greentree gives the Rangers at least something to project forward with, even if it doesn’t come close to replacing Panarin’s production in the short term.
Another notable move came on March 6, when the Rangers sent Sam Carrick to the Buffalo Sabres in exchange for a 2026 third-round pick and a 2026 sixth-round pick from the Chicago Blackhawks. Carrick originally arrived in New York as a low-risk free agent signing, a 32-year-old depth center with limited NHL experience. Yet, he became one of those players every team needs in a deep playoff run, which is why Buffalo saw him as a valuable addition in their Stanley Cup pursuit. If he had stayed, the hard-nosed bottom-six grinder likely would’ve been in the mix for the Steven McDonald Extra Effort Award. In this context, Drury did well turning his rental asset into future draft capital, which is exactly the kind of value move contenders or retools need to make when evaluating depth players at the deadline.
Another smaller but quietly effective move was Drury dealing defenseman Derrick Pouliot to the Chicago Blackhawks in exchange for Aidan Thompson. Pouliot, 32, was a veteran defenseman with 226 NHL games of experience, though he hadn’t appeared at the NHL level since the 2023-24 season and remained buried in Hartford this year. Meanwhile, Thompson, 24, is a former third-round pick who rebuilt his value at the University of Denver, where he finished as a Hobey Baker Award finalist in 2024-25 after scoring 21 goals and recording 55 points in 44 games.
He added eight goals and 22 points in 58 games during his first season in the AHL, split between the Rockford IceHogs and the Hartford Wolf Pack after the March 6 trade. From a roster standpoint, it was a move driven more by organizational depth-chart reality than anything else. Pouliot wasn’t part of the NHL picture, and Drury was able to convert that into a legitimate prospect with upside.
Finally, Drury ended the love-affair with his 2021 first-round selection Brennan Othmann, who was traded to the to the Calgary Flames in exchange for Jacob Battaglia. Othmann, 23, was a bust around these parts. He appeared in 42 NHL games and never found his footing. A change of scenery was ultimately viewed as necessary for both sides. Battaglia, 19, who is currently with the Flint Firebirds of the OHL. He posted 90 points (40 goals, 50 assists) a season ago as a winger and is now in the process of transitioning to center — a move that adds longer-term positional value to his development profile. At worst, this is the Blueshirts resetting a stalled prospect timeline. At best, they’ve added a younger, more versatile forward with the potential to strengthen organizational depth down the middle.
Lastly, on waivers we saw Drury claim Tye Kartye from the Seattle Kraken. The idea behind claiming the 24 year-old was never about finding a hidden scorer, as he had never topped 20 points in Seattle despite playing regular minutes. They wanted to find cheaper depth players who could handle tough bottom-six minutes, and Kartye checked a lot of those boxes. He brought energy, defensive responsibility, and penalty-kill experience. The belief was more that he could stabilize the bottom of the lineup, and help defensively.
Fortunately, once he arrived in New York after the Olympic break, Kartye became a regular in the lineup and never looked back, even finding some offensive confidence. His five-game point streak in March and his two goal, three point season finale against the Tampa Bay Lightning showed there may be more offensive upside there than originally thought. That said, the biggest thing Drury values is Kartye's attention to detail. He remained effective on the penalty kill, played reliable defensive hockey, and proved he could fit alongside the stars who will be sticking around like captain J.T Miller and center Mika Zibanejad. If Kartye can continue being a dependable, physical, penalty-killing bottom-six forward who occasionally chips in offensively, that is exactly the type of affordable player Drury needs to excel while trying to retool the roster.
Grade: C
This one lands in the middle. There were moments where Drury showed willingness to pivot. The midseason “Letter 2.0” signaled a shift toward a younger, faster, more flexible roster, and the trade deadline reflected that approach.
Moving on from the Breadman, getting draft picks back for Carrick and Soucy, and promising prospects for Othmann and Pouliot showed that the organization is ready to move into a retool. However, while taking a step back can be understood, those two steps forward must be seismic if Drury wants to fully win back the trust of his fans.
Where do things go from here?
Drury stated during his exit-day interview that the retool also includes a focus on internal growth, with Jaroslav Chmelař and Adam Sýkora emerging as potential bottom-six options. “Those are certainly going to be great candidates and options moving forward,” he said, signaling that some of the “tenacity” the organization is searching for may already exist within the system.
Regardless, the messaging has to translate into the on-ice product quickly. Defenseman Braden Schneider remains positioned as a key piece of the blue line future despite an uneven season. Drury praised the 24-year-old as a “terrific young right-shot defenseman” and reiterated confidence in his long-term role, even after a year in which he was exposed in top-pair minutes. Yet, the numbers, - a 46.28 GF%, 45.45 CF%, and 44.61 xGF% — reflect a 24 year-old still struggling to handle elevated responsibility.
There’s also the likelihood that Vincent Trocheck is gone. Trocheck still holds significant value as a two-way center and carries a team-friendly contract — three years at a $5.635 million AAV cap hit with a 16-team no-trade clause. However, if the Rangers are truly operating in a retool, then maximizing value on a player like Trocheck must transpire this Summer. The also Rangers hold the No. 5 and No. 26 overall picks in the first round and enter the offseason with $27 million in cap space. So, the real judgment of Drury won’t come from the messaging or even the deadline. It’ll come from how he uses this summer to define a long-term direction for the Broadway Blueshirts.
Add us as a preferred source on Google