Skip to main content

Rangers can take solace knowing they avoided Red Wings-level catastrophe

The Rangers' risks paid off.
ByScott Rogust
Detroit Red Wings v Edmonton Oilers
Detroit Red Wings v Edmonton Oilers | Leila Devlin/GettyImages

Last season was one for the New York Rangers and the fans would like to forget, as they finished last place in the Eastern Conference. The team opted to go for a retool back in January, which meant trading away some of their top players to bring in top prospects, while still trying to put together a winning team.

It was a risky effort by President and General Manager Chris Drury, but through the quarter-way mark of the 2026-27 season, that risk paid off, as the Rangers find themselves in third-place in the Metropolitan Division.

The team is 13-8-1 through 22 games, doing so with Igor Shesterkin out for the rest of the season, Pavel Dorofeyev struggling to score goals, and boasting one of the top penalty kill units in the league. Not to mention, they are seeing the likes of Adam Fox, Alexis Lafreniere, Mika Zibanejad, J.T. Miller, and Tye Kartye all having good-to-great season.

Think aabout it, the Rangers could very well be in the position the Detroit Red Wings are in now, where they have not one, but two of their top players wanting out.

Rangers avoided a Red Wings-like mess after retool announcement

The decision to wave the white flag on the 2025-26 season wasn't an easy one. The team could have committed to a full-on rebuild, but opted to bolster their prospect pool and still trying to put together a playoff-caliber roster.

One of the first moves the team made was trading away Artemi Panarin, their top scorer since his arrival in 2019. It was hard to envision the team trading him, but Panarin knew that the Rangers had no desire to re-sign him after the season. So, the two sides worked close to get a trade done before the Olympic break. With Panarin holding a no-movement clause, the Rangers didn't really hold the edge in negotiations. Panarin wanted to go to the Los Angeles Kings, and the Rangers moved quickly to make it happen, while acquiring prospect Liam Greentree and a conditional 2026 third-round pick.

Then, there was uncertainty surrounding Fox, their top defenseman and quarterback of their powerplay unit. After Fox's return from injury and missing the cut for the United States' Olympic roster, the defenseman wouldn't commit to staying with the Rangers for the future. That created a full-on panic among fans, as Fox potentially wanting out of New York would make the team worse off.

Luckily for the Rangers, Fox was happy with the direction of the franchise after the 2025-26 season, citing the young players they called up and the impact they made in games. So, Fox was more than happy with remaining with the Rangers. This season, he is one of the top defensemen in the game, where he has two goals and 22 assists to his credit through 22 games.

There are correlations to what the Rangers decided to do and what the Red Wings are currently dealing with.

Rangers could be dealing with Dylan Larkin, Simon Edvinsson situations like Red Wings are currently dealing with

The Red Wings are in the midst of a disaster with two of their top players, with seemingly no end in sight.

Back in the offseason. Larkin requested a trade from the Red Wings, with reports indicating that his strained relationship with then-general manager Steve Yzerman playing a role, along with the team's failure to put together a roster that can make the playoffs.

Even with Yzerman stepping down from the role, with Shawn Horcoff stepping in on an interim basis, there is still no end in sight. Even with Larkin expanding his list to 10 teams, the Red Wings have a high asking price for him that no team on his list have matched yet. Larkin refused to expand his trade list so the Red Wings could find more trade partners. He is also currently suspended from the Red Wings with pay due to his refusal to play for the team until he is traded.

With the Rangers, they did know that they weren't going to sign Panarin in the offseason, so they opted to move on from him quickly. While the return is still worth debating, the fact they didn't milk it or let him walk in free agency for nothing is way better than what the Red Wings are dealing with with Larkin.

Then, there's defenseman Simon Edvinsson. Still a restricted free agent, Edvinsson requested a trade from the Red Wings, saying that he didn't plan on signing a new deal with the team. He is away from the team, training in Nashville and most recently, Tempe, Ariz. But now, there is new reporting that shows just how poorly the relationship has soured between player and team.

According to Sportsnet NHL insider Frank Seravalli, Edvinsson has turned down signing multiple team's offer sheets. The reasoning behind it is that Edvinsson doesn't want to allow the Red Wings to match any of those offers. That's how badly the defenseman wants out of Detroit. The clock is ticking for Edvinsson, as he has until Dec. 1 to sign a contract if he wants to play this season. But the favt that Edvinsson is going to that extreme shows how much he does not want to play for the Red Wings any longer.

Again, the Rangers truly lucked out with Fox, as their solid play towards the end of the season had a positive impact on him. The team could very well be dealing with what the Red Wings are with Edvinsson, currently.

The Rangers' decisions this year can be scrutinized, yes, but the early returns are positive. Besides, the Red Wings are having it much worse trying to find ways to move on from two of their top stars. No one is going to want to sign up for that.

Add us as a preferred source on Google