Skip to main content

Rangers need to steer clear of an Evgeni Malkin trade

Maybe not the greatest use of resources.
ByScott Rogust
Boston Bruins v Pittsburgh Penguins
Boston Bruins v Pittsburgh Penguins | Joe Sargent/GettyImages

The New York Rangers defied the odds and the absence of goalie Igor Shesterkin to get off to a strong start to the season. Through 22 games this season, they are 13-8-1 and sit in third place in the Metropolitan Division. If they keep it up, the Rangers could position themselves to be buyers at the trade deadline.

Meanwhile, a division rival is getting prepared to trade away some players, and that's the Pittsburgh Penguins. After shocking the world and making the playoffs last season, the Penguins find themselves in a position where they can rebuild and trade away players. It is something they have to do, considering their superstars are getting closer to retirement. One of their stars that could be dealt before the end of the season could very well be Evgeni Malkin, who is set to hit free agency after this season, where he could feasibly retire.

With trade buzz beginning, the Rangers do make sense as a destination for the longtime rival. But does it actually make sense?

Rangers floated as potential trade destination for Evgeni Malkin

The Athletic's Josh Yohe recently had a mailbag article answering fans' questions (subscription required). When asked about Malkin's three teams he could put on his trade list by his Feb. 1 deadline, Yohe mentioned the Rangers as his guess for one of the teams, behind the Florida Panthers and Tampa Bay Lightning.

"I’ll guess the New York Rangers. Malkin loves former Penguins coach Mike Sullivan, and the Rangers are better than expected this season," writes Yohe.

The Penguins do need to begin building towards their future. As much as it stings to move on from some of their franchise cornerstones, they have to begin finding their replacements. While the Penguins enjoyed a run to the playoffs, they have gotten off to a rough start to this season, thus forcing president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas to make some tough decisions, and it could be moving on from Malkin.

Rangers should avoid the temptation of trading for Evgeni Malkin

Since Mike Sullivan is the head coach, they are going to be linked to a variety of his former players. The Rangers already traded for one of his ex-Penguins players in defenseman Marcus Pettersson. There was also Conor Sheary last season. So it wouldn't be entirely shocking if Sullivan was going to bang on the table for general manager Chris Drury to acquire Malkin.

Bringing in a former rival is always an enticing, yet weird, scenario for any team. For the Rangers, they have dealt with Malkin for 20 consecutive seasons, and he has proven to be a pain to play against. In 81 career games against the Rangers, Malkin has 32 goals and 43 assists to his credit.

The thing is, Malkin is 40 years old. He is putting up decent enough scoring numbers, as he has 17 points (six goals, 11 assists). However, is giving up picks from a draft stock pile that is reduced due to their moves this past offseason for Pettersson, Pavel Dorofeyev, and Joonas Korpisalo for Malkin the best idea? Not really.

Look Malkin would bring familiarity with the Rangers, as he knows Sullivan's system. But, he's never played alongside the players that are on the roster (minus Pettersson). It might take awhile for him to build chemistry in what is going to be a limited run with the team in hopes they make the playoffs. Is that the greatest idea for the Rangers?

Sure, they have been seeking a superstar to bring to New York City for years, but they first had to make Madison Square Garden a viable destination for big time players again. Malkin does fit the role of superstar, but is not the one they should be giving up draft capital for.

It will be interesting to see if Malkin does move forward with a trade request with his list of three teams. If he does, it will be interesting if the Rangers make the cut. Regardless, the Rangers would be better off finding other options to help in their push for a playoff spot, one that could be a factor beyond this season.

Add us as a preferred source on Google