There's something magical about Hockey Night in Canada. The lights, the anthem, the sea of bleu-blanc-rouge echoing through the Bell Centre—it's pure hockey soul. Saturday night, New York Rangers vs. Montreal Canadiens. Two Original Six teams, two franchises that have seen it all. Montreal came in flying—buzzing, scoring, feeling themselves. The Rangers wanted to finish, find rhythm, and prove they can put the puck across the line. They did it four times in an enthralling 4-3 victory that may kickstart a heater we've been teasing throughout the week, as they were getting goalied three straight times.
I'll admit it, I've always had a soft spot for the Habs. Lane Hutson gliding at the blue line, Cole Caufield sniping from impossible angles, my Calder pick Ivan Demidov doing alien things with the puck, Marty St Louis behind the bench, and more. The rapid youth movement is a joy to watch. Yet tonight, I was quickly reminded that joy can turn into anger when your team's on the wrong end of it.
A nightmare start in Montreal
Barely a minute and a half in, the building exploded. Mika Zibanejad tried a quick short-side look that missed wide, and as the puck wrapped around, Matthew Robertson pinched too deep. One bad bounce later, Montreal had a two-on-one, and you just knew. Caufield fed Juraj Slafkovsky, and boom—1–0 Habs. The Bell Centre shook like an earthquake.
Great work by Cole Caufield to force the turnover and then setup Juraj Slafkovsky for a perfect 2v1 goal. #GoHabsGo up 1-0 early. pic.twitter.com/YiAnxiOSbB
— Marc Dumont (@MarcPDumont) October 18, 2025
It's funny, the Blueshirts practiced 35 two-on-ones Friday and scored on three. Montreal needed one to bury theirs. Things went from bad to worse, as the Canadiens' speed was suffocating, waves of red jerseys flying. The Rangers couldn't touch the puck. When Nick Suzuki ripped home a Demidov setup on the power play just 3:42 in, it was 2–0, and I was sitting there more stunned than angry. Marty St. Louis had them playing with swagger, as they met the prestigious occasion. It was five and a half minutes before the Blueshirts even got a shot on net. It finally came from Robertson, who tested Sam Montembeault down the middle—but that was it. Montreal just looked faster, cleaner, hungrier.
A flicker of life
During the first TV timeout, head coach Mike Sullivan, and his assistants David Quinn and Joe Sacco ripped this group a new one behind the bench and they responded by pushing north and playing heavy, before garnering a power play. I wasn't holding my breath—this man- advantage has been atrocious. J.T Miller fumbled passes, overthought plays. Then, after Montembeault robbed Artemi Panarin and Mika Zibanejad once, Mika stepped into his sweet spot on the left circle and hammered home a one-timer. 2–1. Welcome to a sigh of relief disguised as a goal.
Mika Zibanejad - New York Rangers (2)
— NHL Goal Videos (@NHLGoalVideos) October 19, 2025
Power Play Goal pic.twitter.com/M0k7KGaMqo
The visitors hung in from there, even generating a few rushes. Noah Laba took a big hit to make a play—love that from the rookie. The fourth line of Sam Carrick, Adam Edström, and Matt Rempe kept grinding and nearly tied it before the intermission buzzer. Montreal had the speed, but New York had the grit. The second stanza saw the Rangers come out flying, as Miller and Connor Sheary nearly connected on a gorgeous give-and-go. Will Cuylle was buzzing. Sheary again had chances, deflections, tips, he was everywhere. And on the back end, Braden Schneider was quietly bottling everything, winning puck battles, finishing checks, and wiping out Caufield behind the net with one of his best defensive sequences all season.
Jonathan Quick, meanwhile, settled in. He stoned Alex Newhook, then Demidov. Sam Carrick buried Hutson before Montreal's Arber Xhekaj came roaring in for a fight with Carrick. Haymakers everywhere. Bell Centre roaring again. It was old-time hockey.
Sam Carrick has stepped up in all kinds of ways so far this season.
— Jonny Lazarus (@JLazzy23) October 19, 2025
Arber Xhekaj answered for the play on Lane Hutson, but Carrick held his own in this tilt.
Looked like the #NYR bench was juiced from this. pic.twitter.com/ZZVlqPeQqc
The Blueshirts matched Montreal's emotional punch for punch. Alexis Lafrenière hit a post, and Panarin missed a gimme on a 2-on-1 during a late power-play. After two, it was still 2–1 Habs—but the Rangers had taken control. Scoring chances: 16–9 New York. High-danger looks: 7–4 (Finished 13-6 Blueshirts). However, Sullivan's crew had seen this trilogy in three separate barns, so the third period better be good. The Bell Centre lights dimmed, the tension built, and the Blueshirts finally flipped the script.
The comeback chorus
First, Panarin worked it back to the point, Fox let it rip, and captain Miller tipped it home with Lafrenière also providing traffic. First, Panarin worked it back to the point, Fox let it rip, and captain JT Miller tipped it home.
MATTHEW ROBERTSON FOR THE LEAD!
— Rangers Videos (@SNYRangers) October 19, 2025
He gets his first NHL goal 🔥 pic.twitter.com/A8w3Tkqvlw
1:40 later, Panarin made amends for that earlier miss. Mika burst into the zone, fed him perfectly, for a quick release post and in beauty, 4–2 Blueshirts. It marked the breadman's fourth point of the night and lifting the burden of his early-season struggles.
Artemi Panarin tacks on another to extend the lead 👏 pic.twitter.com/AJNLN0cfyY
— Rangers Videos (@SNYRangers) October 19, 2025
Montreal clawed back with a Noah Dobson point shot that Quick probably wanted back, but New York never blinked. Sheary gave his body for the boys blocking shots, Cuylle kept forechecking like a madman, and Fox and Will Borgen closed gaps, slowing Habs rush attempts and zone entries. Quick stopped Caufield in the slot. Mika, a two-way stud in this one, blocked a cross-ice pass as the clock hit zero. The Rangers had done it, 4–3 final.
Chalk it up as a dub for the @NYRangers! 🗽 pic.twitter.com/aRbiNroXvp
— NHL (@NHL) October 19, 2025
This one mattered because after a week of frustration and a nightmare start inside the Habitat, the Blueshirts found a way to play heavy, stay patient, and score when it counted. That's the kind of story which breathes life into a locker room. The Canadiens were fast, flashy, and fun for ten minutes, then proved fragile. The Rangers proved disciplined, determined, and desperate, and on this edition of Hockey Night in Canada, grit beat speed. We rang the Bell at the Bell Centre—and man, it felt good.