The Rangers struggle to find a new identity begins with the questions surrounding their captain

From his brutally honest post-game comments to his struggle to stay healthy during the retool, J.T. Miller is finding out that being the captain of the Rangers in 2026 is his toughest challenge yet.
NHL: JAN 23 Rangers at Sharks
NHL: JAN 23 Rangers at Sharks | Icon Sportswire/GettyImages

As most of the Rangers players — along with head coach Mike Sullivan, assistant coach David Quinn, and Team USA assistant GM Chris Drury, who will also be heading to the Olympic Games — scatter for their much‑needed 19‑day NHL Olympic break, three Rangers players won’t be getting much rest. Mika Zibanejad, Vincent Trocheck, and captain J.T. Miller are heading to Milano Cortina to represent their countries and chase gold.

Miller, meanwhile, heads into the break carrying something heavier than luggage: frustration. After Thursday’s 2–0 shutout loss to the Carolina Hurricanes, he openly admitted he had no answers for what’s gone wrong — a troubling sentiment from the man wearing the “C” during such a brutal season.

“I don’t know,” Miller said. “It hasn’t been good enough the last little while. Try to regroup, freshen up… We just need to enjoy or take time — I literally don’t know. Come back with a better mindset, I guess.”

That’s… not exactly the rallying cry you want from your locker‑room leader. And the truth is, Miller’s post‑game interviews have all hit the same note this season: flat, resigned, and devoid of the spark you expect from the captain of a flagship NHL franchise.

Take the Rangers’ embarrassing 5–2 loss to the Sabres on January 8. Asked about a shorthanded goal against, Miller shrugged: “It sucks, those things happen… not much more to say.” When pressed further, he offered more of the same listless, checked‑out responses.

Or look at January 12 against Seattle — the game immediately following the 10–2 humiliation in Boston. Asked about the team’s sudden dip in energy after the first period, Miller delivered his now‑infamous, “I don’t know, I’m sorry, I don’t know.” That quote didn’t just land poorly; it poured gasoline on an already frustrated fanbase.

Listen, I get it. It’s easy to cherry‑pick the worst moments and soundbites. And I can’t pretend to know what it feels like to face a firing squad of reporters every night for 14 seasons. It has to be exhausting — especially after the media circus he endured in Vancouver.

And historically, Rangers captains have embraced that job. The last three — Jacob Trouba, Ryan McDonagh, and Ryan Callahan — each had their own style, but all three led with conviction. Yes, even Trouba. Say what you want, but his physicality and that legendary helmet toss lit a fire under the 2022 team that stormed to 107 points before Chris Drury torpedoed the chemistry with the Patrick Kane trade. But I digress.

The point is simple: teams often mirror the personality of their captain and coach. Right now, the Rangers look lost, frustrated, and unsure of themselves — and Miller’s public demeanor isn’t helping.

J.T. Miller needs to set aside the emotion, the disappointment, and the fatigue. He needs to lead with purpose, clarity, and presence — qualities worthy of the “C” stitched to his chest.

Hopefully, he returns from the Olympic break with a gold medal around his neck and a renewed attitude in the Rangers locker room. His teammates deserve that. The fans deserve that. And frankly, so does he.

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations