New York Rangers: A Blueprint for a Revamped Blueline

We all know the New York Rangers biggest crutch; their defense. It’s the only thing keeping them from being uber dangerous. Here is a blueprint for how they should go about re-making their blueline.

While the Rangers defense has been better of late, it is still a bottom-tier NHL defense. While the team has only given up 4 goals in their last 3 games, there are the occasional goals like the one below that make you shake your head in disbelief.

With all of that being said, the Rangers are not too far off from being the most dangerous team in the Eastern Conference. It all depends on what they do with their defense. Their forward group is set for years to come, with only one player–Rick Nash–above age 30.

Since they won’t have to worry about that, their defense is their number one priority.

In the following slides, we will take a step by step approach to figure out how the Rangers can solve their defensive woes.

Step 2: Feel out the Trade Market to Bring in a 2nd Pair Defenseman.

While the Rangers probably could outright trade for a number one defenseman with the amount of young forward depth they have, it wouldn’t make much sense. The Rangers shouldn’t destroy a great forward unit to bring in one player.

More from Editorials

• Rangers’ Playoff Redemption Recipe: Grit and Fresh Hopes
• Rangers’ Roster Chatter: Who’s Making the Cut and Who’s in the Penalty Box?
• These Rangers must learn Peter Laviolette’s ropes before they can fly
• Filip Chytil Could Take Major Steps in the 2023-24 Season
• Looking forward to the upcoming season for Artemi Panarin

While a second unit defenseman will cost some assets to acquire too, the asking price won’t be nearly as high.

Take a guy like Cam Fowler, for instance. Fowler is having a career year offensively. He has tallied 10 goals and 16 points so far this season for the Anaheim Ducks. Right now, it looks as if Cam Fowler is not going to be protected in the expansion draft since the Ducks will obviously protect Hampus Lindholm and Sami Vatanen over Fowler and they will be forced to protect Kevin Bieksa due to his no-movement-clause.

With that said, the Ducks will have some incentive to move him since they are most likely going to lose him for nothing anyway. If the Rangers send the Ducks a second-round pick (one of the two they own in 2018) along with a forward prospect or two like Adam Tambellini and a guy like Marek Hrivik who played well at the NHL level this year, it might be enough to get the deal done.

Regardless of who they try to acquire, the Rangers will need to be creative with a move here. If they do acquire a guy like Fowler, that means one of their current rostered defensemen will need to be shipped out.

Step 3: Addition by Subtraction

After the Rangers get their 2nd pair defenseman they will need to ship out one of their current top six. The two guys the Rangers should push hard to trade are Kevin Klein and Marc Staal. I would put Dan Girardi in this mix as well but it is very unlikely that another NHL team would want to bring on a guy like Girardi–unless maybe a team like Colorado wants to bring in a guy who’s been around the block a few times, but like I said, very unlikely.

Moving Marc Staal does a few things for the Rangers. The first thing it does is open up another spot to protect a defenseman in the upcoming expansion draft. Staal has a no-movement clause which will force the Rangers to protect him along with two other defensemen come the draft at the end of the season–McDonagh and Girardi being the other two.

Trading Staal also opens up some cap room or the Rangers to make a move in the offseason.

The incentive to trade Staal simply would be to dump his salary. It is unlikely that the Rangers would get much for the often injured Staal. If they were to get a mid-round pick or two for him, that would be a respectable coup at this point.

More from Blue Line Station

• Blake Wheeler’s Broadway Calling: Why He Chose the Rangers
• Rangers’ Playoff Redemption Recipe: Grit and Fresh Hopes
• Rangers’ Roster Chatter: Who’s Making the Cut and Who’s in the Penalty Box?
• Jacque Plante Trade Tree Between the Rangers and Canadiens
• These Rangers must learn Peter Laviolette’s ropes before they can fly

Klein has declined in a big way since last season. The Rangers better move him fast before he loses all of his trade value. Klein is one of the few Rangers willing to drop the gloves to stand up for a teammate, but it is still a move they need to make.

Again, if they could land a 4th or 5th round pick for Klein, it would be a good move.

Step 4: Play the Kids

At this point, if the Rangers made all the moves I have mentioned above, their defense would look like this;

McDonagh-Fowler

Holden-Skjei

Clendening-Girardi

Or some kind of combination of that.

Here is where you call up a guy like Ryan Graves and slot him into the lineup, whether it be for Girardi–the best option–or Clendening–the most likely option knowing Alain Vigneault.

This isn’t the strongest defense in the world by any stretch of the imagination, but it’s an improvement from what they have been rolling out for most of the season. This is only the beginning of the plan, as the rest of it can’t be finished till the offseason.

Step 5: Offseason Moves

The day the season ends, the Rangers need to buyout Girardi for any of this to work. I do think that they will end up doing this after giving him another season to see if he could round back into the form of yesteryears. He didn’t and now it is time to move on.

Eyes On Isles

When that happens, the Rangers would open up another one of their expansion draft slots for their defenseman. They then could slot McDonagh, Fowler and Holden into those spots, while Skjei and Graves will be exempt from the draft anyway.

After the expansion draft, they will have a few more moves to make before they can rest.

The first of which being the master plan all along; signing Kevin Shattenkirk via free agency. The 27-year-old Shattenkirk is from New York originally and would be open to coming here a season removed from being named an assistant captain over in St. Louis. Shattenkirk, a righty offensive defenseman would be a perfect fit within the Rangers’ system.

The team would likely need to allocate a pretty penny in his contract, but it would be worth it. His contract will likely need to be one of six years in length, paying him around $6.5-7 million annually.

With Shattenkirk on board, the Rangers defense would look like this;

McDonagh-Shattenkirk

Fowler-Skjei

Holden-Graves/Clendening

Much better, right?

Step 6: An Optional Move

This is an idea that I am going to take right from the keyboard of our very own Tyler Kluepfel. The Rangers should test Nick Holden’s market and see if they can’t recoup some major assets off of his breakout season.

Holden will turn 30 in May. He cannot be expected to put up the same offensive numbers he’s been putting up ever again. The Rangers can recoup a couple picks for Holden probably around the second and third round. This would be great asset management by the team. It also would allow them to restock their farm system which is bare of quality prospects on defense.

If they are to do that, they can either sign a sixth defenseman off of free agency, make another low-cost trade like they did for Holden this past offseason or just roll with Graves and Clendening as their 5th and 6th defenseman and make a few depth defense signings and call it a day.

Next: Top 3 Defensemen Who the Rangers Could Call Up

As bleak as their situation may look right now, while it won’t be easy, the Rangers can fix this defense and be an elite team by the 2017-2018 season but Jeff Gorton and the rest of the team’s front office will need to be creative to make it work.